Chef-owner Paolo Pece, a master chef certified by the Italian Culinary Institute from Naples, Italy, serves award-winning “authentic, contemporary Italian cuisine” featuring seafood, pork, steak, pasta, and poultry. Featuring rotating art exhibits and contemporary decor, Cafe Atlantico was deemed “a St. Augustine treasure” by Florida Times Union, featured in Best Romantic Escapes in Florida, and has won numerous awards: three diamonds from AAA, Florida Trend’s Top 500 Restaurants in Florida, and Best Ethnic Dining in the “Taste of St. Augustine.” Serving dinner nightly 5 p.m. till closing. Extensive wine list. Catering. Located south of Beaches Pier.