The Restaurant Times St. Augustine
  • Home
  • CURRENT ISSUE
  • Recommended Dining Guide
    • A - B >
      • A1A Beachside Diner
      • Andaman Asian Bistro
      • Ann O'Malley's Deli & Pub
      • Aunt Kate's on the River
      • Avilés Restaurant & Lounge
      • Back 40 A1A
      • Beachcomber Restaurant
      • Bin 39 Wine Bar
      • The Black Molly Grill
      • BlackFly The Restaurant
    • C - D >
      • Café del Hidalgo
      • Cantina Louie
      • Casa de Vino 57
      • Casa Reina Taqueiria • Tequila
      • Castaway Cantina
      • Catch 27
      • Cheba Hut Toasted Subs
      • Chez L'Amour
      • Collage
      • Cone Heads Ice Cream
      • Crabby's Beachside
      • Diane's Natural Market & Cafe
    • E - G >
      • Florida Cracker Cafe
      • The Floridian
      • Frisky Cat Café
      • Gringos Tacos
    • H - K >
      • Harry's Seafood • Bar & Grille
      • Harvest & Reel
      • Hillary's Chicago Pizza
      • Kafe Kava
      • Kingfish Grill
    • L - M >
      • La Cocina at the Cellar Upstairs Wine Bar & Restaurant
      • La Strada Italian Restaurant
      • Lobstah on a Roll
      • Mikato Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
      • The Milltop Tavern
    • N - O >
      • Ned's Southside Kitchen
      • Nero's Waterfront Cafe
      • O.C. White's Seafood & Spirits
    • P - Q >
      • Pizzalley's Chianti Room Italian Ristorante
      • PK's Roosevelt Room
      • Playa Bowls St. Augustine
      • Purple Olive
    • R - S >
      • The Raintree
      • Redfrog & McToad's Pub-N-Grub
      • The Reef
      • St. Augustine Sailing
      • Sakada Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
      • Salt Life Food Shack
      • Saltwater Cowboys
      • San Sebastian Winery
      • Schooner’s Seafood House
      • Sunset Grille
      • Surfside Kitchen
    • T - V >
      • Taco Libre
      • Tini Martini Bar
      • Village Inn
    • W - Z >
      • Witty Whisker Cat Cafe
      • Zaba's
  • St. Augustine Marketplace
    • Shopping • Edible Treats >
      • The Ancient Olive
      • Annagem Jewelry and Art Gallery
      • Fifi's Fine Resale Apparel
      • Neff Jewelers
      • Sandpiper Boutique
      • Travelpro Outlet
    • Things to Do >
      • Anastasia Mini Golf
      • Limelight Theatre
      • Magic Hideaway
      • Third Space Improv
    • Services • Wellness >
      • Casa Bella Home Styling & Staging
      • Deprey Chiropractic
      • Island Framers & Gallery
      • Sharon Hill Massage
    • Real Estate • Vacation Rentals • Event Rentals >
      • Sunshine Realty
      • White Horse Ranch Events
      • Yallaha at Griffin Estate
    • Local Products >
      • St. Augustine's Forever Young Perfume >
        • Find a St. Augustine Retailer
        • Order Online
  • About Us
    • Get SOCIAL!
    • Get a Copy!
    • Advertise
    • Meet the Publishers
    • How to Contact Us
  • Contact Us
    • How to Contact Us
    • FOR DISTRIBUTORS: NEED MORE COPIES DELIVERED
    • Make a Payment
Picture
Hillary's Chicago Pizza - The Restaurant Times St. Augustine, Florida
Picture
Hillary's Chicago Pizza
​1974 U.S. 1 South 

(904) 209-5960 • HillarysChicagoPizza.com
order online
In the craveable department, Hillary's Chicago Pizza brings authentic specialties from the Windy City to the Ancient City! Owners Hillary and Bruce Lake—native Chicagoans who moved to Northeast Florida in 2018 to be closer to family—are no strangers to the industry. They owned a neighborhood bar in Chicago and offer the same vibe in their newest venture. The specialties of the house are thin crispy "Tavern Style" pizza as well as the hearty Deep Dish pies that are part of Chicago's culinary legacy. The menu also offers specialty sandwiches, salads and irresistible desserts. Hillary's offers 24 beers on tap, with a focus on artisanal Florida brews, and wines at a comfortable bar and dining room. If it is your first time having Chicago Deep Dish Pizza, please be prepared to wait. Hillary's makes everything from scratch, in house. Deep Dish Pizzas are indeed deep (about 2"), rolled out by hand and have a lot of ingredients— a full pie takes at least 45 minutes to cook, sometimes longer. For that reason, call ahead ordering is recommended, especially at the weekend. Takeout and catering. Delivery is now available via DOORDASH. Open Tues. 4-10 p.m.; Wed.-Fri.11 a.m.-10 p.m.; Sat. noon-11 p.m.; Sun. noon-7 p.m.; closed Mon. Starting in April, Hillary's will be open for lunch on Tuesdays!

SEE OUR MENU
Follow Us on Facebook
See Us on Instagram

HOME
CONTACT US
© 2025 Publishing Partners, Inc. St. Augustine, Florida.
St. Johns County Tourism Member • Member of Women's Food Alliance
  • Home
  • CURRENT ISSUE
  • Recommended Dining Guide
    • A - B >
      • A1A Beachside Diner
      • Andaman Asian Bistro
      • Ann O'Malley's Deli & Pub
      • Aunt Kate's on the River
      • Avilés Restaurant & Lounge
      • Back 40 A1A
      • Beachcomber Restaurant
      • Bin 39 Wine Bar
      • The Black Molly Grill
      • BlackFly The Restaurant
    • C - D >
      • Café del Hidalgo
      • Cantina Louie
      • Casa de Vino 57
      • Casa Reina Taqueiria • Tequila
      • Castaway Cantina
      • Catch 27
      • Cheba Hut Toasted Subs
      • Chez L'Amour
      • Collage
      • Cone Heads Ice Cream
      • Crabby's Beachside
      • Diane's Natural Market & Cafe
    • E - G >
      • Florida Cracker Cafe
      • The Floridian
      • Frisky Cat Café
      • Gringos Tacos
    • H - K >
      • Harry's Seafood • Bar & Grille
      • Harvest & Reel
      • Hillary's Chicago Pizza
      • Kafe Kava
      • Kingfish Grill
    • L - M >
      • La Cocina at the Cellar Upstairs Wine Bar & Restaurant
      • La Strada Italian Restaurant
      • Lobstah on a Roll
      • Mikato Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
      • The Milltop Tavern
    • N - O >
      • Ned's Southside Kitchen
      • Nero's Waterfront Cafe
      • O.C. White's Seafood & Spirits
    • P - Q >
      • Pizzalley's Chianti Room Italian Ristorante
      • PK's Roosevelt Room
      • Playa Bowls St. Augustine
      • Purple Olive
    • R - S >
      • The Raintree
      • Redfrog & McToad's Pub-N-Grub
      • The Reef
      • St. Augustine Sailing
      • Sakada Japanese Steakhouse & Sushi Bar
      • Salt Life Food Shack
      • Saltwater Cowboys
      • San Sebastian Winery
      • Schooner’s Seafood House
      • Sunset Grille
      • Surfside Kitchen
    • T - V >
      • Taco Libre
      • Tini Martini Bar
      • Village Inn
    • W - Z >
      • Witty Whisker Cat Cafe
      • Zaba's
  • St. Augustine Marketplace
    • Shopping • Edible Treats >
      • The Ancient Olive
      • Annagem Jewelry and Art Gallery
      • Fifi's Fine Resale Apparel
      • Neff Jewelers
      • Sandpiper Boutique
      • Travelpro Outlet
    • Things to Do >
      • Anastasia Mini Golf
      • Limelight Theatre
      • Magic Hideaway
      • Third Space Improv
    • Services • Wellness >
      • Casa Bella Home Styling & Staging
      • Deprey Chiropractic
      • Island Framers & Gallery
      • Sharon Hill Massage
    • Real Estate • Vacation Rentals • Event Rentals >
      • Sunshine Realty
      • White Horse Ranch Events
      • Yallaha at Griffin Estate
    • Local Products >
      • St. Augustine's Forever Young Perfume >
        • Find a St. Augustine Retailer
        • Order Online
  • About Us
    • Get SOCIAL!
    • Get a Copy!
    • Advertise
    • Meet the Publishers
    • How to Contact Us
  • Contact Us
    • How to Contact Us
    • FOR DISTRIBUTORS: NEED MORE COPIES DELIVERED
    • Make a Payment